Friday, June 29, 2007

Give Kids Credit (Not that kind of credit)

This morning, I was perusing an article about teaching kids about money and the author suggested that you should start giving an allowance when kids begin to understand the concepts of saving and spending. I agree. Then the author said this should happend around first grade. First grade? Hmmm...my kids certainly have learned about the concept of spending money much earlier than that and saving money is something they can understand by the time they reach kindergarten (if not before). We need to give kids more credit (not that kind of credit) for their ability to grasp concepts earlier and, therefore, I think you should start them on an allowance earlier than first grade. Earlier is better, because the forces teaching kids to be irreponsible with money are certainly not waiting and an allowance is one of the best tools to start teaching your kids about the value of money. Let them make mistakes with the money young, seek out the teachable moments when they make them, and hopefully they will learn and we can raise a generation of kids much smarter than us when it comes to money.

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Young Kids and Money - Rich or Poor

My family is always sending me articles relevant to our business and today's mail proved to be no exception. My Dad, a retired banker, sent me a piece from the June 2007 issue of the Parsippany monthly. Though the article addresses four topics for "Teaching Children the Financial Facts of Life" (article by Steven Brisgel), two items resonate for me. At the beginning of the article, Steven mentions that many young people may receive "sizable inheritances." Kids of wealth have difficulty with "value of money" issues just as poor or middle-class children do. It likely stems from the same problem, though, and that is the emphasis society or parents put on material things. Which brings me to the Steven's first (and arguably most important) topic, "Be a Role Model." This is one of the most difficult areas for any of us to address, particularly if we have developed any bad habits (which would be about 100% of us) over our lifetimes. We all know that kids do what you do, not what you say, and it is IMPERATIVE that we are mindful of this axiom. One thing that we try to do in our household is be mindful of our use of the terms "need" and "want." Put your attention on this during the day and you'll see what I mean. Adjust what you say accordingly - making sure that you are using the terms properly. And gently correct your children when they identify a want as a need. Nobody really needs a nightgown emblazoned with their favorite character. Do they?

Friday, November 17, 2006

Lessons for Preschoolers

Numerous parents have asked me if there are any resources on the web to help them teach their preschool kids about money. One of the best set of resources I've come across is distributed free by the Credit Union National Association, Thrive by Five. The lessons are super simple (very important for this age group) and pretty fun. Try them out and let me know what works for you.

All the lessons are in both English and Spanish. Pretty cool.

-John

Friday, November 03, 2006

"This Doesn't Fit Into Our Budget"

My 3-year-old always asks to buy stuff when we go into a store. To anyone who has kids, this certainly isn't a shocker. So how do we deal with it? In her book, Money Still Doesn't Grow on Trees, Neale S. Godfrey says that if you should remember only one piece of information from her book, it's the phrase, "This doesn't fit into our budget." My wife and I use this line all the time. Our daughter is three so she keeps pushing, but I think she's starting to get the point. Why this line? Neale looks at the primary alternative line, "We can't afford it," and says "...that it doesn't mean anything. In fact, you probably can afford it." Saying that something doesn't fit into a budget will also help us segueway into a larger discussion about budgets when the time comes (of course, we think three is a little young). I have a friend who is also a financial representative and I was impressed by his dogged use of the "budget" line with his 4-year-old the last time we were out. It worked to quash the requests pretty effectively. I was also secretly giddy that his kid suffered from the same consumption issues as our daughter. Let me know what's working for you.

Neale's book is available at most major booksellers.

-John

Monday, October 23, 2006

All About Allowance

I have been asked by more than one parent recently about allowances, particularly for the 2-6 year-old age group to which we cater. I culled through some experts’ books and articles to come up with some pointers that are (hopefully) useful to help you get started:

When? Determine when you think your kids can handle it. I know from experience with my own three-year-old that she is too young (for an allowance, though certainly not too young to discuss and handle money). Five or six seemed to be the consensus amongst experts. Try this poll to see what 5000+ parents think, http://life.familyeducation.com/allowance/parenting/43766.html?detoured=1

Teaching Tool: Let your kids know that allowance is a tool for them to learn how to manage money, but don’t get upset when they manage it poorly. Use it as a teaching tool, not a disciplinary one.

Allowance/Chores: Strongly consider not tying allowance to chores. Though I’ve seen some reasoning to the contrary, all the sources (below) for this post suggest that chores and allowance should be separate. “In my experience, and according to many psychologists and counselors, an allowance should not be tied to personal achievement [grades]…or doing chores around the house…Give an allowance to teach your children the basics of good money management.” -Paul Lermitte from Making Allowances.

Watch yourself: If you’re concerned about how they will treat their money (and you should be), pay particular attention to your own money habits and try to be consistent with what you tell your kids and what you do.

Responsibility: Help them build personal responsibility; let them make mistakes.

Calculating the allowance is a little more difficult and a more personal decision. One prevailing thought (seen on Pearson Education’s Family Education site among others) is to give your child a weekly dollar amount that is half their age ($3/week for a six-year-old). Parent response on this particular site was vehemently against that idea because of the paltry allowance it would create. David Owen in First National Bank of Dad makes a very strong case for a substantial allowance AND providing a substantial interest rate to the children to teach the power of saving and compounding. The experts generally agreed that it’s most sensible to determine what the child will be responsible for (a list that will likely grow as your child grows) and provide them with enough for that. Whenever you start, whether it be four, five or six, keep it simple. Janet Bodnar in Dollars & Sense for Kids (aka “Dr. Tightwad”) suggests making them responsible for one thing (sweets on supermarket trips, trinkets on trips to Target, etc.) Also, give them money in denominations that allow for doling it up and saving, sharing (donating) or spending it (five ones instead of a five-dollar bill).

For more in depth information, the following books were my sources for this post:

Janet Bodnar’s Dollars & Sense for Kids
Joline Godfrey’s Raising Financially Fit Kids
Paul Lermitte’s Making Allowances
David Owen’s The First National Bank of Dad
Pearson Education Family Education Site (featuring National PTA material)

Thursday, October 12, 2006

Kids and Ads

Advertisments are the primary way in which kids are hit with the "spend, spend, spend" message. Parents can help their kids understand how to analyze ads. Commonsense Media has an short, useful paper about how to protect kids under seven from being exploited by advertisters. The main key questions Commonsense lists are as follows:

1. Who created this message?
2. What words, images, and sounds are used to attrach my attention?
3. What is really being "sold" in this message?
4. What does this message mean to me?

These may seem like somewhat adult questions, but with advertisers targeting the massive kids market as young as early as two, it's time we equip our kids with the tools to spend smart.

Wednesday, October 04, 2006

Teaching kids to share - a simple idea

I was talking to a good friend recently and she mentioned a great, easy way to help teach your kids to share their money. If you happen to go to a place of worship that takes donations, have them regularly donate some amount from their "Share" piggy banks (or wherever they're saving it) to church on a weekly basis (or however often you make it). I thought this simple piece of advice was very useful because kids typically have such little money to donate and doing so to larger charities requires a little more work and might even be considered a bit too abstract for them to understand. In the church example, they can see that their money is going to something more tangible and they will feel more a part of the congregation. As any of you with kids know, anything they can do to make them feel more "adult" really makes their day. Of course, we parents are in no rush for them to grow up...but that's a story for another blog.